FanCasts

Sit back, relax and listen to our FREE Football Podcasts. Subscribe 4 FREE to get your teams show each week.

Blogs

Intelligent, articulate, opinion. Read, rate and comment!

Banter

Create your own discussion and debate - Sign up and get involved!
Tagged: Premiership, Wigan

Football FanCast columnist Rob Facey reacts to Dave Whelan's comments regarding the state of the Premier League and wonders if the Wigan chairman has a point when it comes to defending the number of foreign players in the country.

Following on from Sir David Richards comments that the Premier League has contributed to the downfall of the national team has been met with criticism from Premier League chairmen, most prominently Wigan's Dave Whelan. But who is in the right?

Richards' views are in stark contrast to Premier League chief executive Richard Scudamore who claims that there is no link between the scarceness of English players in the Premier League and the team's failure to qualify to Euro 2008.

"I don't think he's fit to be the chairman of the Premier League and what he has said goes against the Premier League," Whelan told The Guardian.

"It is very unfair what he is saying. He knows the problems we have."

"We have to import foreign players because we haven't got the youngsters coming through. But that goes in phases. Football is not a rolling production line."

Whelan did have words of advice for youngsters in the future, stating:

"They shouldn't sign for the big boys. They should sign for local clubs."

Is Whelan right? Should youngsters be encouraged to join smaller, local clubs rather than following the bright lights of London, Liverpool or Manchester?

Were David Richards comments out of order or has he just stated the blindingly obvious? What is the answer to solve the discrepancy between domestic power yet failure on the national level?

Click here for live match reports

Grp B Croatia vs. Germany. 17.00

Grp B Austria vs. Poland. 19:45

Poll:

  • No votes yet
Latics
Picture of Latics
He is the only man in
He is the only man in football that talks common sense. How funny it is to see two men in the PL committee squabling, somes up the organisation for me.

Tree & Crown
Picture of Tree & Crown
"Our Dave" doesn't mince his
"Our Dave" doesn't mince his words! It's refreshing to hear somebody say it as it is. Scudamore and Richards are the football worlds Bill & Ben! I completly agree with his point on our younger players being sucked into the "Big Club" web. It's difficult for parents/parent to say no when Liverpool or Man Utd coming knocking on the door. Only for them to dissappear into the ethos or as is the case end up playing for "smaller local clubs" dare I say like Little Wigan!