FanCasts

Sit back, relax and listen to our FREE Football Podcasts. Subscribe 4 FREE to get your teams show each week.

Blogs

Intelligent, articulate, opinion. Read, rate and comment!

Banter

Create your own discussion and debate - Sign up and get involved!
Tagged: Premiership

Football FanCast columnist Jerome Johnstone looks into the definition of rivalry in football and poses the question of which is the biggest in England?

If there was one thing that was apparent with our recent debate, then Elland Rd was well and truly considered the most fearsome ground in England. Most away supporters considered the trip to Yorkshire as the most butt clenching experience due to the intensity of the atmosphere and having been there on many occasions, I for one would wholeheartedly agree. Leeds United are by no means a rival to my football club, geographically we are miles apart and we have never really challenged for the same honours - it is just the fact we are two of England's biggest football clubs and we just want to get one over on them.

For me rivalry is the integral part of football and what makes it so interesting. The banter between the teams, the mocking of each other's fans and it just adds to the intensity of the proceedings. With all due respect to teams like a Wigan or Reading, they hardly set the pulses racing as a supporter and they are certainly not the first fixture you look for when the new lists are released at the end of June. You look for the big games that bring with them the atmosphere and these are the games you would pay twice the admission fee to watch them.

So how do you define rivalry and as a football club should it just openly depend on whoever your near neighbours are? Liverpool and Everton are two of England's great football clubs but I bet many Reds fan will consider Manchester United a greater rival. Spurs and Arsenal is not the most pleasant of atmospheres but is it any worse than a West Ham or Chelsea visit, are they more intense? Who would Manchester United consider their great rivals, City, Liverpool or the dubbed war of the rose's showdown against Leeds?

I guess there will never be a definitive answer or an explanation for rivalry; it just solely depends on geographical or historic reasons. We at Football FanCast are on a mission to find out what is considered the biggest rivalry in English football? Is it merely a local derby? North vs South? Regional or does it solely depend on historical encounters between two sides?

It is the debate "Which is the biggest rivalry in England" that will be discussed on the WKD Sports Shed show on Nuts TV, so submit your vote and comment and get your opinion seen by many.

HAVE YOUR SAY:

 

Poll:

  • No votes yet
Feds
Picture of Feds
It would have to be
It would have to be Liverpool Manyoo, the most succesful teams this country has ever seen so head to head there is no bigger game.

Dexter
Picture of Dexter
Spurs Arsenal is massive but
Spurs Arsenal is massive but the biggest rivalry is certainly United Liverpool game, as Feds said the fact they are the most successful teams says all you need to know.

Hazy days
Picture of Hazy days
Leeds vs United creates an
Leeds vs United creates an atmos like no other one in football, pure hatred on the pitch as well as off it.

JimB
Picture of JimB
The biggest rivalry in
The biggest rivalry in England? Certainly not Leeds v Man Utd. There's just too much of a gap in the status of the two clubs. And besides, Leeds are only third on Man Utd's list of hated, relatively local rivals - behind Liverpool and Man City. Without a doubt, the biggest rivalry in English football is Man Utd v Liverpool. Anyone who says otherwise is deluded.

Gunnerdinho
Picture of Gunnerdinho
I'll go for Arsenal v Spurs
I'll go for Arsenal v Spurs because it's the most entertaining and I'm an Arsenal fan:). In terms of intensity it would probably be Liverpool v United or Leeds v United when it was.

Russ
Picture of Russ
I'm bias but I'd say it's
I'm bias but I'd say it's Arsenal v Spurs as it's a true Derby match in the sense that the teams are only a few miles apart in the same city. There is a lot of history and bad feeling from Spurs with Arsenal moving from South to North London and for getting promted to the 1st Division under dodgy circumstances at Spurs expense in 1919. Sol Cambell moving across too! Man Utds biggest derbies are against teams from different cities and Utd v City & Liverpool v Everton are not in the same league as an Arsenal Spurs game. Arsenal Chelsea has been tense recently due to the 2 teams usually challenging to be Londons top club but West Ham is not really a massive game.

ChrisFromSalford
Picture of ChrisFromSalford
Us vs Leeds! From a
Us vs Leeds! From a supporter since 1963 I lived through the peak ages of the rivalry. Leeds are the team I despise more than any other, including Liverpool and City. Revie's Leeds United was by far the best team in the country during the 60's & 70's and we weren't a patch on them for most of that. When we won those games it was brilliant, such a buzz, Leeds was the game you looked out for. When Man United got back to the first division in 1975 Leeds were winding down and falling, we took Jordan and McQueen and generally a better team. The fans, the hatred between us and them is something more greater than anything. Hope to see Leeds back asap so we can kick 7 bells out of the dirty Yorkshire so and sos asap on and off the field. City are a poor club, Liverpool is a rivalry bought up by skysports and everyone believed them. Leeds is the real rivalry.

Rob
Picture of Rob
I think for hatred Pompey v
I think for hatred Pompey v Saints takes some beating!

Fergie
Picture of Fergie
Leeds united v Man United is
Leeds united v Man United is just pure evil

pablo
Picture of pablo
Leeds Vs Manure...
Leeds Vs Manure...