Facebook  |  iTunes | Twitter | Desktop |
Sunday 5th Jul | Login | Create an account
                                                All the latest Premier League football news, premiership team news, championship news, transfer news, football injuries, live football scores and more...
Custom Search

BLOG (YOUR OPINION)

George Best vs Cristiano Ronaldo - Who is Manchester United's finest wing wizard?
Posted by: Stephen Darwin , on Thu 14 Feb 2008
 
 
Besty

FFC columnist Stephen Darwin concludes his "Who's the greatest series" on Manchester United. In his final part, Stephen turns his attention to Cristiano Ronaldo and George Best to find out who is the finest wing wizard to play at Old Trafford.

Cristiano Ronaldo has set the Premier League alight over the last couple of seasons. The Portuguese winger possesses an array of dazzling tricks, a sublime turn of pace and a goal-scoring record that continues to defy the role expected of a traditional wide midfielder. It is no wonder that the Madeira-born wizard has been compared to George Best in recent times.

Best was an extraordinary footballer and undeniably one of the greatest players to ever grace the game. The Northern Irishman would humiliate defenders with his attacking guile and instantly became a favourite among supporters from all over the world. So is all the furore surrounding Ronaldo a tad premature; or can the Premier League's current top marksmen realistically claim to be the ‘Best'?

George Best

On 22nd May 1946 a genuine legend was born. George Best undoubtedly experienced some tough times during his career but this does little to tarnish the unquestionable ability of the Belfast born superstar with a football at his feet. It was by no means an understatement when United scout Bob Bishop announced that he had found a 'genius' in Best at the tender age of 15.

Best would glide past defenders effortlessly and it would seem like the ball was glued to his foot as he drifted away from challenge after challenge. Often the only way to stop the brilliance of Best was to ultimately admit defeat and foul him. Georgie boasted an incredible goal-scoring record too, with 179 goals in all competitions for Manchester United. Best's importance at Old Trafford was underlined by the unprecedented achievement of being the club's leading scorer in five consecutive campaigns.

In only his second season with the Red Devils, Best secured his first league title with the club and would go on to produce one of the most memorable performances of his career a year later. In United's 5-1 triumph over Benfica in the 1966 European Cup quarter final, Best scored a fantastic brace that included a truly remarkable solo run. The Portuguese press were quick to acknowledge Best's supreme class and famously labelled him 'El Beatle'.

A second league title would follow in 1967 and Best proved once again to be the thorn in Benfica's side in the 1968 European Cup Final. In a significantly tight affair, Best gave United a 2-1 extra-time lead that helped inspire the Red Devils to a 4-1 victory and the coveted tag of European Champions. In what had been a magnificent season for Manchester United, Best was crowned both PFA and European Footballer of the Year.

On the international scene, Best represented Northern Ireland 37 times and found the net on 6 occasions. Best has long been described as the greatest player never to have graced a major international tournament - a considerable shame for the decisive winger, as he would have certainly excelled at a World Cup or European Championship.

Best was frequently under the media spotlight and was the first footballer to experience the showbiz lifestyle. Not only an icon on the pitch, Best's appearance made him an extremely popular figure off it too, with modelling assignments and public appearances all part of the Best repertoire. Best had clearly set a trend as we witness the idolisation of the Beckham's and Ronaldo's of the modern era, where modelling contracts are highly lucrative and professional footballers are under the constant scrutiny of the media.

Cristiano Ronaldo

In a similar vein to George Best, it was apparent that United had unearthed a special talent in the form of Cristiano Ronaldo even before he had stepped foot in Manchester. During a pre-season friendly in 2003 that saw United succumb to a 3-1 defeat against Sporting Lisbon, Ronaldo put in a typically impressive performance that prompted a selection of United's playing staff to encourage Sir Alex to sign the Portuguese maestro. The United manager duly obliged, parting with £12.24 million to secure Ronaldo's signature - a substantial bargain for a player of such unrivalled class.

In contrast to Best, Ronaldo prefers to tantalise and tease defenders with an assortment of tricks before producing an end product. There have been numerous critics of Ronaldo's final ball and willingness to go down but it is apparent that he has addressed these parts of his game in an attempt to become the ultimate footballer.

The manner in which Ronaldo reacted to the post World Cup anger of English supporters is something to be admired. Despite a tirade of abuse from away fans, Cristiano's personality shone through and the Portuguese set off on a mission to silence the boo boys. Infact, the 2006/2007 season proved to be particularly vibrant for United as Ronaldo's scintillating skill, electric pace and clinical finishing helped the Manchester club to their first league title in four years. Ronaldo's superlative form didn't go unnoticed and the 23 year-old picked up a number of individual accolades including the PFA Players Player and Young Player of the Year and the Football Writers Footballer of the Year awards.

Ronaldo has pushed on to unbelievably greater heights this season and his career continues to flourish at United. The exciting winger has already scored 27 goals in all competitive matches this term and is a constant attacking threat whenever he features in the famous red shirt. Ronaldo has a refreshing self belief that is clearly indestructible and he will always strive to improve despite being at the peak of his game.

The Portuguese national team have also reaped the rewards of possessing one of the finest footballers in world football. Cristiano has notched up 36 caps and 12 goals in his relatively short international career. A defeat to Greece in the Final of Euro 2004 quashed Ronaldo's dreams of winning a trophy with his country but with Euro 2008 just around the corner, I'm sure Portugal will be challenging come the end of the tournament.

The Result

Manchester United have been fortunate enough to witness the development of some outstanding number 7's in their illustrious history. Best and Ronaldo stake a legitimate claim of being the greatest and separating the two is an ultimately difficult proposition. Both technically astute and wonderfully gifted footballers but by appearing in 466 matches and consistently performing at the highest level, Best's commitment to Manchester United ever so slightly tilts the contest in my opinion. Yet with Ronaldo thriving at the current rate, there is no reason why he cannot become the indisputable king of the number 7 shirt in the future. As long as the twinkle toed talent resists the allure of Real Madrid, he may well cement himself in United's history as a true legend of the club.

 

Click Here to read Part One- Robson vs Keane
Click Here to read Part Two- Bruce/Pallister vs Vidic/Ferdinand

 

Average: 5 (1 vote)
 
Contact us
 
Send to a friend
 
Printable version
 
©  Action Images  
©  Action Images  
 

Comments

I must be one of the few

I must be one of the few people who actually sees Ronaldo as the better player. I loved Bestie but Ronaldo just has a bit more to his game generally.

I think bestie conceded that

I think bestie conceded that he saw Ronaldo as his natural successor.

Good analysis Steve but

Good analysis Steve but there was no one better than Bestie. You often wonder what the guy could have achieved on the pitches they play on today. Would Ronaldo have been able to compete against the likes of Chopper Harris?

Cristiano Ronaldo is the

Cristiano Ronaldo is the best player ever to don the No.7 shirt. I loved Cantona but Ronaldo did it against the best in England and Europe.

What about Giggsy?? I rate

What about Giggsy?? I rate him as high as Best and Ronaldo has a few seasons to go before proving himself as great as Flying Ryan!!!

he is the best of the

he is the best of the best.he's got it all.he is not just a footballer he is an entertainer on the field.lots of love..keep it up.

Best became a legend and

Best became a legend and will be remembered as one of the greats and that was in a time when footballing heroes were few and far between and the focus in the press or tabloids wasn't as great as it is today (until Best came along that is). Ronaldo is a modern day legend but in a slightly different way. The game has changed (maybe easier in terms of tackling etc) and the tabloid spotlight falls firmly on him as he has produced some excellent football. But in 20 years time will we be talking about Ronaldo in the same vein as Best? I don't know but I believe, for the moment, Best has the edge over Ronaldo as the game was tougher then and he still managed to play some dazzling football, but Ronaldo has many years left in him and there is alot more to come.

Best, sorry but you have

Best, sorry but you have been outdone.. Twinkle feet wins!

It is impossible to

It is impossible to compaire. Different ages! So people say football was harder back then, but nowadays with all the cience applied to football competition is much harder ... one thing is certain much harder to score ( you just need to look at stats). CURIOSITY: Today 16th of March Ronaldo has scored his 31st goal this season (one goal away from Best) but with almost less 20 games. This is a huge achievement !!! 81 goals and 39 assists in his 5th season (225 games)is also HUGE! Best track record at Man U is 11 seasons (361 games) 138 goals.

Sorry Twinkle Toes, Bestie

Sorry Twinkle Toes, Bestie will always be the Best!
Write your own articles, personalise your page and create quick links to your Favouriate sites.
A fans resource for all your match day, ticket and statistical needs - Login and contribute yourself.
Football Commentary Experience: a day you will never forget, try your hand at football commentary