Facebook  |  iTunes | Twitter | Desktop |
Saturday 4th Jul | Login | Create an account
                                                All the latest Premier League football news, premiership team news, championship news, transfer news, football injuries, live football scores and more...
Custom Search

BLOG (YOUR OPINION)

Time for the Sven to scrap the lone striking role at Manchester City?
Posted by: David Mooney , on Fri 28 Mar 2008
 
 

Football FanCast columnist Dave Mooney suggests that England aren't the only side that are struggling with a lone striker, as a former Three Lions boss is currently establishing at Eastlands.

That lone striker role is definitely a specialist position. It's a role that needs someone powerful and strong, quick, and with a lot of stamina, an opportunist and an excellent finisher.

It's a position that Manchester City have used constantly throughout their season and one they've had trouble filling. Vassell, Bianchi, Mpenza and Benjani have all tried it this season, with varying degrees of success.

Starting with the now-midfielder, former-striker, Darius Vassell, it's clear that he is not a lone striker. His best season for City was while he was playing up front with Andy Cole as a supporting striker. He's never going to bag 20 goals a season, but he will get himself firmly into double figures when he's got a strike partner of any quality. However, both Pearce and Sven appear to have moulded the lad into a winger, with his pace and ability to keep going like an energizer bunny on speed, he's a good candidate to balance the team when Petrov is playing wide-left.

Sven splashed out on Rolando Bianchi in the summer and, while he scored consistently in his time at City, he never really settled. His pace wasn't his biggest asset, but he could certainly head the ball well.

Mpenza has recently turned down a loan move to Leicester, and rightly so in my opinion, as I think he can still do a job for us. He is powerful and nippy, but his finishing lets him down at times yet he's always willing to chase a ball down and can put a lot of pressure on the defence in doing so.

I'm probably about to upset a large number of Blues fans, but I think Benjani is another player who isn't a lone striker. I know the best way to win the City fans over is to score the winning goal on your debut, away at Old Trafford, and, to be fair to the lad, he always gives his best for the team. But he just doesn't look like he's capable of scoring when playing alone up front.

At the beginning of the season the midfield was chipping in with a large number of goals. But since Elano lost some of his form and Michael Johnson needed abdominal surgery, that source has dried up a little.

Don't get me wrong, I've been overjoyed with the way this season has panned out. In fact, we're well ahead of where any of us expected us to be after last season, but the one thing that has disappointed me in recent weeks has been Sven's reluctance to try something new.

He said himself in the Manchester Evening News that he thought City had been "found out" and that our style of play had become common knowledge. Added to the fact that Elano, in an interview with The Independent, told of how he found it difficult because he was being marked out of the game; it seems to me that it might be time to gamble and try two strikers for the final part of the season.

Personally, I think at pairing of Benjani and Mpenza could work wonders, especially as Elano is struggling and Ireland's form appears to be dipping in and out. It could be the right time to switch it about in the midfield to, what about trying Geovanni instead?

With Bojinov coming back to fitness as the season comes to an end, and Caicedo looking like a very promising, young signing; 4-4-2 seems to be the way to go for me. It would give the strike partnership some more support and it's now the last thing the opposition will expect - with our current system being used since the opening day.

The future certainly looks bright, but with a bit of a personnel change and a change of shape, that future could end up looking much, much brighter.

 

 

No votes yet
 
Contact us
 
Send to a friend
 
Printable version
 
©  Action Images  
©  Action Images  
 

Comments

I think the problem as you

I think the problem as you point out is the need of the quality front man. The system does work, Chelsea have been proof of that. Berbatov would be the perfect striker for that role although I cant see us affording him.

We are in desperate need of

We are in desperate need of some strikers and how Sven thought that Benjani was the answer I would never know. Absolute waste of space; I think we were too hasty in getting rid of Miller - certainly deserved a chance.

I would hate the prospect of

I would hate the prospect of Benjani Mpenza partnership, talk about blind leading the blind.

Mpenza would struggle in a

Mpenza would struggle in a 5-man forward line, and Vasell will never get into double figures in my lifetime. Benjani played as a lone striker often at Portsmouth and did ok, he just needs time to gel with t'others. Right.... shoot me .... but I'd take Beckham for the right side... I'll get my coat...

right - there's lone striker

right - there's lone striker and there's alone striker. What Chelsea do is play lone striker. But Joe Cole and the rest of the midfield aren't exactly backwards in coming forwards. Watch Chelsea attack with their "lone striker" and you'll struggle to keep tabs on the various midfielders and defenders running all over the place to overwhelm their opponent's defence. What Benjani was doing at Portsmouth was lone striker but again with the midfield getting forwards to support. He is clearly capable of playing the role but the role at City is different. City play the "alone" striker. The single man making the runs marked out of the game but 3 defenders. That fella. The system that so frustrated Petrov against Bolton because basically he'd get the ball then have to hold off a ton of players while our midfield chugged up the pitch to be available to him. It doesn't matter who plays up front. With no supporting midfield runs he is a doddle to neutralise. What matters is who supports him and right now we don't look able to dismantle a half-decent defence because our midfield isn't making them suffer.

Ishmael Miller is not a

Ishmael Miller is not a Premiership player and I doubt that he will become one. He has the touch of someone whose legs are made of rubber and the balance of a 6 month old child. We can't keep him for 5 years and hope that one day he becomes good enough to be a squad player. Our problem is a lack of pace and energy. Like another poster made clear, we need bodies to go forward to support the likes of Petrov and Benjani. We did this at Old Trafford, probably more than any other game this season. It worked a treat. I'm sure Sven / Backe is telling the players to do this but they are not carrying out his orders. I'm sure Sven will bring in the players (in the summer) that can execute his tactics. In Sven we trust

**EDIT** Miller may become a

**EDIT** Miller may become a Prem player with the Baggies but he will never be a PREM player - if you know what I mean.

At a recent supporters

At a recent supporters meeting Sven stated we played a lone striker to protect Hamman.So why not try two strikers when he was suspended and a younger more agile player was on the park or is it a case of consolidation for this season!Sven was very convincing on the future and on his dream team for next season 2 wins over united don't make a season but its a good start!!
Write your own articles, personalise your page and create quick links to your Favouriate sites.
A fans resource for all your match day, ticket and statistical needs - Login and contribute yourself.
Football Commentary Experience: a day you will never forget, try your hand at football commentary