FanCasts

Sit back, relax and listen to our FREE Football Podcasts. Subscribe 4 FREE to get your teams show each week.

Blogs

Intelligent, articulate, opinion. Read, rate and comment!

Banter

Create your own discussion and debate - Sign up and get involved!
Tagged: Liverpool

Football FanCast columnist Alex Dimond feels that Rafa Benitez is approaching a crossroads in his Liverpool career.

In terms of tradition, stature and support, Liverpool FC is among the biggest clubs in the world. The club is steeped in history and silverware, at a level only a handful of clubs throughout the world can contend with. The club has long led the way in English football, and has been at the forefront of the cosmopolitan transformation the sport has witnessed in the recent times. To that extent, it is surprising to learn that the Anfield club's new £7million signing, Andrea Dossena, will become the first Italian international to play for the red half of Merseyside in its 116 year history.

The former Udinese left-back arrives on Merseyside with a fair bit of pressure on his shoulders, as he is widely expected to slot straight into the left-back berth of Rafa Benitez's side. His move is even believed to have paved the way for John Arne Riise to leave the club, removing any safety net he might have had. Expected to perform from Day 1, there will be nowhere to hide for the 26 year- old. As a free transfer arrival, Swiss right-back Phillipe Degen will no doubt be given time to prove his worth to the Kop - but Dossena will not be so lucky. As a result, Dossena is the first of many big summer transfers that will carry on their shoulders the transfer reputation of Mr Benitez.

The Spanish manager's record in the transfer market is somewhat patchy, with expensive signings such as Luis Garcia, Mark Gonzalez and Fernando Morientes failing to make any sort of long term impact at the club. His successes in the transfer market, most obviously Fernando Torres and Javier Mascherano, have both commanded top draw fees. Yet beyond these two marquee names, you fear there are very few Liverpool players that would find their way into another ‘Big Four' team. Carragher and Gerrard would surely find a place, but Benitez cannot claim credit for their signatures. He does, however, have to take responsibility for the signings of Dirk Kuyt, Peter Crouch and Jermaine Pennant - players who have all commanded significant transfer fees. While his recent signings have shown signs of improvement- Skrtel (£6m) has settled well and youngsters Lucas, Agger and Plessis look destined for great careers - they have yet to look like they will turn Liverpool into genuine title contenders.

Does Dossena have the talent to set the Premiership alight? Does he have the ability to challenge Evra, Cole et al as the best left-back in the league? Looking at his record, the omens don't look promising. As a youngster coming into a talented Verona side, the Italian had to suffer a disappointing relegation and two seasons in Serie B before Udinese eventually snapped him up. Initially struggling to impress with the Zebrette, he dropped out of favour with then manager Serse Cosmi, who sent him on loan to Serie A strugglers Treviso to gain some form. Dossena suffered his second relegation from Serie A with the minnows, and it was only in the last two seasons that he managed to assert himself at Udinese - helping the StadioFruiliclub toa reasonable 7thplace finish last season. While he has been capped by Italy, he failed to make the final squad for Euro 2008.

Nevertheless, Dossena enjoys a burgeoning reputation in his home country, where he is highly regarded asan attacking fullback with good delivery and an eye for goal. His defensive qualities have not gone unnoticed either, and he is especially respected for performing best against top-class opposition. Such qualities bode well for Liverpool, who have lacked security at the position in recent times, and also tend to rely on their fullbacks for width and attacking thrust. From the stands, Dossena and Liverpool look a perfect fit - but if this doesn't translate to the pitch then surely questions will be asked.

Rafa Benitez is at a crossroads in his Liverpool career. If, as we are led to believe, Roman Abramovich is looking for a manager with a proven record in the Champions League, then there are only a handful of viable candidates. With Carlo Ancelotti seemingly committed to Milan, and Frank Rijkaard perhaps disenchanted with football at the moment, Benitez stands ahead of the crowd. He has clearly been affected and affronted by the Gillett/Hicks saga, which suggests he would be open to any advances that may come from Chelsea (complete with oodles of roubles) or another top club. Yet no advances appear to be forthcoming. Money will be available for the new Blues manager, but only if it is spent on targets that are sure to enhance the current squad - from his time on Merseyside, Benitez is yet to prove he can be trusted with that responsibility. Even his record with youth signings (Gabriel Paletta, anyone?) is open to some ridicule. The fact he has been unable to provide truly attractive football at Anfield is another black mark against his name. While he was winning big trophies, such criticisms were answered in the most effective way, but times change. It is damning that Barcelona were nonchalant about interviewing the Spaniard for their top job - preferring instead to appoint the inexperienced (club legend) Josep Guardiola. Rafa's stock is not as high as it once was.

Dossena himself is getting married this weekend, and whether being a newlywed will help or hinder his arrival in a new country is open to debate - but it will surely only serve to heighten the pressure on him next season. If he, and any future summer additions to Liverpool's squad,can produce the goods on the pitch next season then the Reds will undoubtedly have a great opportunity to seriously challenge for their first title in 19 years. But if he doesn't, you fear Benitez and Liverpool might be the ones heading for a divorce.

NB - Alex Dimond is competing in our Bloggers Euro Championship so if you can give his article a rating in the voting box, it would be greatly appreciated.

EUROS 2008 LIVE MATCH COMMENTARY: CLICK HERE

Grp C Romania vs. France. 17:00

Grp C Netherlands vs. Italy. 19:45

 

Poll:

  • Average: 5 (2 votes)
Anfield Rd
Picture of Anfield Rd
It is true that we havent
It is true that we havent been spectacular in the market but I believe Rafa will get it right.

Fed
Picture of Fed
I agree that Rafa will have
I agree that Rafa will have no excuse if we fail this season. The signings have been disappointing but that is due to a lack of funds.

Thido
Picture of Thido
what are you kidding me??
what are you kidding me?? this is clearly an article that isn't balanced. you state that rafa's signing leave a lot to be desired besides the one he spent money for. who saw mascherano as succeeding in england? he was languishing in the reserves at west ham. Rafa picks him up and he's now one of the top holding midfielders in the world. he's signed ryan babel, clearly one of the leading talents in the game at the moment. Xabi alonso anyone? another top midfielder, and then you have peter crouch. rafa's signed him and he's become an england international, and scored against top opposition, everyone says he should be playing for liverpool more, but that's a different story. he's got quality which is why he should play more! little arguement with pennant, he's not the best but it's not say these managers don't have flops, forlan, veron anyone? or how about stepanovs and wiltord? or maybe boulahrouz and tiago? luis garcia is a cult legend and everyone was sad to see him go. rafa isn't going to chelsea, certainly not, and to suggest otherwise proves delusion. IN RAFA WE TRUST!!

Rafa The Gaffer
Picture of Rafa The Gaffer
Rafa's last four signings
Rafa's last four signings have been Mascherano, Babel, Torres and Skrtel. All top quality. When given the money he has produced. If you say his youngsters aren't any better, why have we just won the reserves league with no player over 21? Palletta was one failure, Carson was signed for 750k, Anderson as a swap for reserve player John Welsh, Nemeth, Insua, Plessis are moving up to the first team this year. Pacheco, San Jose, Gulasci, Hobbs, Huth all have great potential. Poor article really, just choosing a couple of wrongs to like an invalid point without looking at the full facts.

LFC 4 Life
Picture of LFC 4 Life
Why do writers want to
Why do writers want to pretend that money doesn't matter in football? "Dirk Kuyt, Peter Crouch and Jermaine Pennant - players who have all commanded significant transfer fees" compared to Drogba, Essien, Rooney, Ferdinand et al these "significant" transfer fees are minimal. This is why Torres and Mascherano have been so successful... good players cost money!!!!!!!!!!!

J Griffiths
Picture of J Griffiths
I was under the impression
I was under the impression that Liverpool had 2 left-backs other than Riise - Fabio Aurelio and Emiliano Insua - vying for a 1st team spot, so maybe Dossena won't just walk into the side. Aurelio was comfortable in all the European Cup games and his injury and consequent replacement was a key factor in Liverpool not winning the CL semi. Insua, meanwhile, has starred for the Reserve side and when he came on at Birmingham Liverpool suddenly had an attacking outlet instead of a Norwegian plodder. Unfortunately, Liverpool have to sell players to generate the money to buy, which is why Benitez settled for Crouch until he could afford Torres, Gonzalez until he could get Babel, Pennant until he can get ???? Paletta was a gamble who undoubtedly will be a good player, but needed to stay in Argentina for 2-3 years until he could develop. Garcia would probably still be at the club, but he was one of the few players we had that could command a decent fee, and was a useful bargaining tool in the Torres transfer.

Carradona
Picture of Carradona
stupid article! theres no
stupid article! theres no need to add to this debate the people above me have it bang on apart from any mention of reina!! great signing! if you want to talk about wasted money look no further than mourhino.... duff... shev.... now those are laughable signings!

torres 09
Picture of torres 09
clearly the writer of this
clearly the writer of this article does not know football. in relation to rafa's signing's garcia was quite an important player for us, instrumental in winning number 5. also reina,alonso and agger were good signings, reina is the best 'keeper in the premiership! not make it into other big four teams...are you taking the [*@!$]? lehmann? agger when fit is an excellent defender and although alonso has not had the best season he is an excellent midfielder, and whats more rafa will make a profit selling them on. terrible article. YNWA

Sugan Naidoo
Picture of Sugan Naidoo
Alex is clearly in the wrong
Alex is clearly in the wrong profession, you're smoking something powerful mate. It's clear to see that Rafa's buying players that he can afford, can he really compete for the likes of Lahm, Alves as wingbacks/sweepers? No!Why? Because it's clear to see, we're can't afford that level of footballers. Dossena's not the best in Europe but he's improved his level of football, known to have a good work ethic and judging by market related prices currently, that's what you get for 6-7mil! As for the quip regarding his record of eyeing out youngsters, really now! Mate, stop trying to attract controversy to your articles by writing crap because simply the bigger picture will tell you that LFC reserves have just won the reserve lge with a host of young talent in there, i bet all that talent just stumbled upon Anfield whilst on a tour? Palletta? Ok, didn't work out, Gonzales, Morientes? they just couldn't adapt and all these players were signed within his 1st 3yrs of his current tenure whilst we still qualify for the Champs Lge every year, mind you if you can't remember, we won it in his 1st year packed with deadwood and made the finals again in Athens in 2007! Fergie & Wenger have squandered more on signings that never made the grade @ all yet Rafa get's tweaked for a handful of poor signings within his first 3-4yrs. Crouch? I think he was a pretty good signing, earning his Eng. caps but there's now way he's going to beat Torres to a starting lineup and Rafa's new formation doesn't warrant a starting position for Crouch unfortunately, too bad but we can easily get 10-12mil for him, not bad hey for an average Joe who was laughed @ when we signed him. Kuyt? Not a resounding success in goalscoring but he plays with heart & determination & very useful on the right of late besides, we paid 9mil for him because we couldn't afford the first options like Villa, Eto and Torres then! Pennant? Again, Rafa enters the market for Simao, Jaoquin & even Alves who can play as a winger but guess what? We couldn't afford it because Rick Parry couldn't pull his thumb out fast enough and spend the extra 2-3mil over & above the prices for Alves or Simao which where both around the regions of 12 mil then. Presently? Alves get sold to Barca for 25mil and Simao was sold to Atletico for between 17-19 mil last season. The point i'm making overall is that Rafa can only buy what he affords and that generally are the alternatives to initial targets hence the purchase of Pennant and Bellamy as a striker of whom we made a minimal profit when he was sold to West Ham. Mate, forget about wrting pieces of crap that you might call football journalism until you stop wearing the blinkers! As for Barca approaching him, they knew they stood no chance cos the Rafalution's still on!

Alex_Dimond
Picture of Alex_Dimond
Posts: 61
Joined: 2008-04-15
Vidic £7m, Evra £5.5m. I
Vidic £7m, Evra £5.5m. I don't have any great fondness for Man Utd, but those two transfer fees illustrate that you don't have to spend big to get big. Skrtel and Dossena together will cost more than those two - will they prove themselves to be of the same class? Skrtel is solid but no Vidic, so a lot of pressure rides on Dossena. Benitez himself has shown he can get good players for reasonable fees - Agger comes to mind - so why have so many others flopped? If he doesn't have the vast resources to spend on great players, why doesn't he source the unheralded gems - like Wenger and Ferguson have? Yes the youth team has a lot of talent, but they are not ready for regular first team football next season - and by the time they are it might be too late for Rafa. Contrary to what you might construe from the article, I quite like Rafa and would like to see Liverpool do well. But I think, with the current American turmoil, that another trophyless season might lead to Liverpool parting ways with Benitez, in much the same way they did with Houllier. Because, whether they spend £8m or £80m, Gillett and Hicks will expect to see some returns on their money. Benitez has spent about £75m net throughout his tenure, but are they realistically any closer to capturing the Premiership?