FanCasts

Sit back, relax and listen to our FREE Football Podcasts. Subscribe 4 FREE to get your teams show each week.

Blogs

Intelligent, articulate, opinion. Read, rate and comment!

Banter

Create your own discussion and debate - Sign up and get involved!
Tagged: England

Football FanCast columnist Luke Raine cannot understand why Middlesbrough winger Stewart Downing is constantly the fall guy when it comes to England's failings.

For too long now Stewart Downing has taken far too much of the blame for England's inability to qualify for the 2008 European Championships. If Downing hadn't played under Steve McClaren during his time at Middlesbrough there is little doubt he would have had a smoother ride from the England fans.

People are too quick to jump on Downing when he pulls on the white shirt. He didn't have the best of games on Saturday and was rightly substituted based on the opening 45 minutes of the game. However in previous friendly matches under Capello he has looked bright and given the side natural width on the left hand side when he has come on.

People will say I am biased because I am a Middlesbrough fan. I would argue against this by saying that I have first hand knowledge of just how good Downing can be. The term "big fish in a small pond" has been used repeatedly over the last 48 hours, but this is extremely unfair in my opinion.

When Downing pulls on an England shirt he isn't the same player, but that isn't his fault. Even before the game started against Andorra Downing couldn't win because the fans were completely against him from the off. If he had created chances and looked dangerous it would be because England were playing against limited opposition. If he had a bad game and England were struggling then it would be his fault.

Psychologically it must be difficult for a player to go out and perform in the knowledge that virtually none of his own fans want him on the pitch, simply because of his links to the previous unsuccessful regime.

Downing is no pub player. Ten Premier League goals and just as many assists last season can confirm that. The difference is that when he plays in a red shirt the fans get behind him. Maybe the England "fans" who are so damning of each one of his performances should look at how to get the best out of players before they judge.

If Emile Heskey plays on Wednesday, which looks likely then it will be interesting to see who starts on the flanks. It is almost certain that Downing won't after being judged on 45 minutes of football by the fans, press and manager, but that also leaves the question about who will provide the ammunition to get the best out of the Wigan centre forward.

Joe Cole isn't a winger; he won't get to the by-line and get crosses into the box. The same can be said about David Beckham, who is also likely to start the game. I would personally have chosen Ashley Young, who provided so many assists last season. John Carew is a similar type of player to Heskey and his delivery from set pieces is immaculate - another thing that England will be relying on heavily in Zagreb.

Yet Young doesn't feature in the squad, along with Michael Owen. These two omissions made my eyebrows raise the most. Managers live and die by these decisions - lets just hope Capello is still breathing come Thursday morning.

 

Poll:

  • Average: 4.8 (4 votes)
Frank
Picture of Frank
It is the England way and
It is the England way and they always need a scapegoat for their failings. The fact that the likes of Liverpool are after him shows what a class act he is.

Dexter
Picture of Dexter
You will never please
You will never please anyone. Call me a traditionalist but I actually like playing players in their correct positions. Probably find we would be more successful as a nation if we did.

Burt
Picture of Burt
You are never going to
You are never going to please everyone. The media do nothing for Downings cause and the ignorant supporters just buy into everything they read, shame really.

brillant_downing
Picture of brillant_downing
Downing is a wicked player
Downing is a wicked player he looked quality lately then he has to get undermined by ashley cole who managed to mark him out of the game same thing would have happened to young. It wouldnt surprise me if he ends up at one of the big clubs in europe i.e. barca, arsenal and man ud coz he is so technically brilliant he is an out and out winger and a playmaker in one body. England is full of deadwood like lampard, a cole, heskey and rooney who prefer to pick up their huge wages at their clubs than play for the three lions, its sad, but true, but some of these looser fans love these players so they pick on the up and coming player which is downing who took over hargreaves as the scapegoat of a overhyped squad. being loyal to middlesbrough hasnt helped, but the spuds, villa dont deserve a player like him to be honest i prefer middlesbrough to these hyped up clubs who have the most arrogant and vindictive fans ever.

Redcar Red
Picture of Redcar Red
These are the same fans that
These are the same fans that generally disgrace and besmirch the flag and the nation by drunken, abusive, unruly and neanderthal behaviour when "supporting" their country abroad. "England Football fans" and "open minded enlightened intellect" are not two phrases that sit comfortably side by side. Any player that scores 10 goals in the Premiership from midfield for a team that spent all season fighting relegation has proved he has more ability than someone who plays for a cushy side littered with mercenary foreign megastar millionaires. Problem for Downing is that Ashley Cole likes to get wide down the wing for England and cannot play with a natural left winger as he gets in his way. Our midfield don't know what to do with a left winger as they instinctively go right as they are not used to having a serious left sided option. Consequence of this is that Downing starts to drift inside looking to be involved where he is not at his best and needing to use his right foot and like wise so does Joe Cole who is right footed therefore looks a better option. Problem lies with tactics and the Manager making the players stick to a game plan, don't be surprised if Capello sticks with Downing as HE decides the tactics not the "wags and the glamour boys" as it was under MacLaren. For the average travelling Engerlund luvin, tattoed, beer swilling, pot bellied, perennial depressive whose sole purpose is to blame their lot in life on everything and everyone but themselves wallowing jointly with their Southern softy Journo's seeking to appease their editors readership figures, praise would be an extremely unlikely outcome for any player outside of the sacrosanct Manchelsearsepool Utd stables.

marric
Picture of marric
I agree with redcar red.
I agree with redcar red. I've said for some time that the problem on the England left wing is Ashley Cole. He has an ego the size of a large country and puts himself ahead of the team. It winds me up the way that he insists on overlapping to put the final ball across. The problem is he can't cross. He needs to adjust his play to be the full back that puts Downing in to make the final cross. Can anyone can remember a time that Ashley Cole has put in a good cross, attacked the goal or done anything that makes him look like a player you would want at the attacking end of the pitch? He is (or was?) a really good defender and he should be told to get on with that and help in the attack not try and run it. Problem is that his ego won't allow him to take a supporting role. I think Downing is the quality left winger in the country. Give him time and a chance and players that give him the ball and support rather than hinder him. He'll come good. Whilst we are on I quite like Joe Cole as a central or right midfielder. As a left winger he's useless. I get sick of counting his step overs. When he does do something good (which he still can, even when stuck on the left wing) it is because he has moved into a central position where he can cause some damage. Really it is a repeated theme - choose a system, select the best players for that position to play in each position. Don't try and shoehorn the "best" players into positions where they just can't play.